Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ginny Murtaugh's avatar

What you say here is so true. I am a retired dentist and all most people need to do to reduce prevalence of decay and gum disease is floss daily and brush for 3 minutes once a day. Doesn't take much time or cost much either, but do they do it? Mostly No! Do they know they should? Yes! It was sad to see hard teeth go soft due to a lack of dental homecare!

Also in Positive Psychology they talk about the voice of refusal, which is the inner narrative of I am not good enough, I can't do that or other fake reasons to not pursue what would be good for your well-being. I think the key is to value yourself, you are here, you are worth spending effort on getting your body and mind in good condition to live to your full potential during your lifetime. Go for it! The effort is worth it and when you floss be sure to floss the teeth you want to keep!

Leadership Land's avatar

"Resistance" (in general terms) is a problem I often see with the implementation of self-help literature, leadership training materials, and the translation of Stoic philosophy into Stoic behavior.

When you break it down, it comes down to brain vs. heart.

Brain says "I should do XYZ" because Steven Covey/Jim Collins/Marcus Aurelius says that it works.

Heart says "Yeah, but that makes me anxious/ashamed/guilty/angry."

Or, heart initially agrees. Then a moment of weakness arises, and gluttony/hubris/sloth/lust/envy seizes control.

Brain then joins the conspiracy against the self by making excuses.

"You weren't ready."

"You can start tomorrow when it's convenient."

"You can start when you feel motivated to do it."

Self-help books, training materials, and philosophic meditation work a for self-selecting crowd. The authors preach to a choir, filled with singers who only need a little reminder to go back to what they were doing before. The preachers' job is to keep the choir immersed in the Right Way, and the rest usually takes care of itself.

But for everyone else? They have unresolved emotional hangups. They start out with good intentions, but they end up spiraling back into a heart-brain conspiracy. The smarter the brain, the better it is at rationalizing failure and confirmation-biasing whatever preconceived notions it already had.

Getting the second group to think their way through an emotional problem is a Sisyphean task. I don't think ancient OR modern philosophy is equipped to deal with the second group.

10 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?